Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

There's nothing to understand really. Tesla is a meme stock, and will keep rising as long as Elon and others keep hyping it up.




I don't understand why this keeps working. The dude doing the hyping is widely hated.

67% of Americans have said they'll never consider buying a Tesla. 56% cite Musk as either the entire reason or part of the reason. [0]

Tesla IS Elon Musk. Without him they're nothing, with him they can't access 2/3rds of the market. Why would anyone invest in that?

[0] https://www.yahoo.com/news/two-thirds-of-americans-now-say-t...


TSLA investors:

* don't believe the 67% will follow through with that after experiencing FSD

* don't need 67% of Americans to purchase the car. Robotaxi use is plenty.

* look beyond the American market and its pathetic 5% EV share.


Personally, I suspect they're very wrong about the first two points, but that's just my opinion.

Thanks for explaining the other side of it.


FSD is going to wipe everything off.

I’ve tried v13 few weeks ago, knowing it works so well. Still got shocked how good it is.

They’ll have to drop the price of it tho, but even then 10M cars * $100 per month is $12b of revenue per year.


How is that a Tesla thing though?

I'm fairly certain every auto manufacturer and many non-auto manufacturers are working on it. I doubt they'll be able to patent anything truly important to the process, since others beat them to the market with most of it. Or am I missing something essential?


Remember how everyone kept saying tesla is doomed because any minute now the old OEMs were going to storm in and kill their EV business? In actuality, those OEMs are getting killed by Tesla and Chinese startups. You are making the same argument for autonomy. Old OEMS cannot compete in this space at all. Waymo cannot compete on price with Tesla.

> Waymo cannot compete on price with Tesla

It's a race between how fast Waymo's COGS can decline and how fast Tesla's FSD can achieve actual self-driving. At this moment, given all the evidence available, my inclination is that Waymo is in a better spot.


I don’t think your inclination is unreasonable. Having taken probably like a hundred rides with about an even Tesla/Waymo split in SF, Teslas feel smoother and less robotic, but of course if they felt safety was where it needs to be, they’d be driverless by now.

It’s a bit of a bet. It feels like Tesla is real close, and if they get there, Waymo has no way to compete with Tesla’s manufacturing prowess and vertical integration.


Sure, they're a bit ahead but Mercedes has level 3 self driving and they didnt celebrate killing a bunch of people (and not lowering the deficit) by prancing around with a chainsaw.[0]

I feel like people will be willing to wait until next year for the Alphabet or Mercedes version, but maybe I'm overestimating the average person's attention span or underestimating how far behind the competition is.

[0] https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-new-yorker-documentary...


When I looked for videos of the Mercedes L3 in action a while ago all I could find were videos showing it doing stuff the Tesla FSD could do easily 5 years ago. Has it improved a lot recently?

The mercedes L3 thing is a gimped press gimmick/vaporware. You won’t a single non-press video from an owner just using it. Not a single one.

can you show me how to order a vehicle with this drive pilot?

I'm sure you know more about it than I do. I'm certainly not an expert.

I can say though that when my brother bought his first Tesla he paid thousands of dollars for FSD, which was supposed to be released "any day now." It's been many years and as far as I can tell it's still not REALLY here (in the sense that most people would mean it).

I know that the plural of anecdote is not data, but... The Tesla that he bought originally all those years ago is actually gone now. He had one of the earlier versions of FSD enabled and passed out behind the wheel. Tesla, in their infinite wisdom, decided that if you let go of the wheel for too long they should just completely disable the self driving (at least in that version). So naturally when the driver became incapacitated it just disengaged self driving completely and let the vehicle drive straight into a tree as "punishment" for daring to let go of the wheel for too long. Nobody was hurt, but the vehicle was totaled. It could have been much worse though.

It's such an obvious design flaw. "Driverless 2000 pound missile hurtling down the highway at 55 mpg" is the one failure mode you would think they'd avoid at all costs, rather than using it as the safety fallback. When people talk about how great Tesla engineering is I just kind of shrug.


This is completely made up and/or your brother lied. Teslas always came to a slow stop if no driver attention was detected. Originally just slowly stopping in lane, now actually pulling over.

> How is that a Tesla thing though?

It's not. Waymo could license a version of its stack using the Android model (specifies a minimum sensor suite OEMs have to qualify models on).


> I’ve tried v13 few weeks ago, knowing it works so well. Still got shocked how good it is.

You're not in a position to makes those claims. People think that if it works for them, it's great, which is nonsense of course.


> FSD is going to wipe everything off.

Then why are Tesla's sales down globally?


Stock valuations are not a democracy of public opinion, they are the product of investors putting their money into the stock.

Musk is a shit human, but to an investor, everything he touches turns to gold. Whether his companies make anything useful doesn't matter, what matters is that the stock price in his companies goes up, so people give him more money. This works until it doesn't.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: